The Health Care Case: The Supreme Court's Decision and Its Implications

The Supreme Court's decision in the Health Care Case, NFIB v. Sebelius, gripped the nation's attention during the spring of 2012. No one could have predicted the strange coalition of justices and arguments that would eventually lead the Court to uphold the Affordable Care Act's principal provisions. The constitutional case against the ACA was originally written off as frivolous, but after oral argument at the Court, many predicted that the unthinkable had now become likely. When the Supreme Court delivered its complicated and fractured decision, it offered new interpretations to four different clauses in the Constitution. This volume gathers together reactions to the decision from an ideologically diverse selection of the nation's leading scholars of constitutional, administrative, and health law. They offer novel insights into the meaning of the health care decision for President Obama, the Roberts Court, and the debate over constitutional interpretation.


About the Author
Nathaniel Persily is the Charles Keller Beekman Professor of Law and Political Science at Columbia Law School.

Gillian Metzger is the Vice Dean and Stanley H. Fuld Professor of Law at Columbia Law School.

Trevor Morrison is the Liviu Librescu Professor of Law at Columbia Law School.